Skip to content

Classes with private #fields are not treated as distinct when returned from functions #62664

Closed as duplicate

Description

@p2js

🔎 Search Terms

"class from functions", "classes returned from functions", "class type" functions, "ES2020", "private fields", "#private"

🕗 Version & Regression Information

I believe this behavior has not changed since the introduction of private #fields in classes. I reviewed the FAQ about anything relating to classes with #fields.

⏯ Playground Link

https://www.typescriptlang.org/play/?ssl=17&ssc=42&pln=1&pc=1#code/MYGwhgzhAECC0G9oGIwC5oQC4CcCWAdgOYDc0wA9gdjgK7BYU4AU6muhRAlItFgBZ4IAOlTQAvNDDQAvrIBQoSDABCvVBhqcylarnqMWbLcR5IBQ0dMnS5M+fJABTLFIzxJBJwHc4zAEQAEk4gIBT+XCSOLtAARhhqnj5+QSFhEWQA9JnQAKI4OEwYACoAngAOTtAA5LDV0ELQBBSuynhEBGCxznwUfBVV1SrVwtAACoWVOFilNaj1hP2VNXXQOE4AZk44MIxS0AAmeBtb6wSuALZOF7HbfPxgrsBgBM2ut1LAwE5QTgfQG0KF2g3jwFgIS0Gw2E8myeQKTAau34VQOPzw63+tweADc8BRaDhoCj1g55BtaAQGPiIVgflhmGZ5NAWWsXISIUooNAAHJgK7-JAadj4Yg6Kg0AxMViaDimXgWERiGxkOzyezRVwAYQkfHpjKizlcABFdXTsAaHEbyLqvL4tQEAIwZTWHDAzSoUDY2pK+Y1OjLQOE8vrbQo4IA

💻 Code

class A { #a: string; constructor(a: string) { this.#a = a } }
class B { #a: string; constructor(a: string) { this.#a = a } }

let a: A = new A("Hello");
let b: B = new A("Hello"); // Error: Type 'A' is not assignable to type 'B'. Property '#a' in type 'A' refers to a different member that cannot be accessed from within type 'B'.
// Error is the desired behaviour here


function test() {
    return class Named { #a: string; constructor(a: string) { this.#a = a; } }
}

let C = test();
let D = test();

let c = new C("1");
let d: typeof c = new D("1"); // No error

🙁 Actual behavior

a value of type D can be assigned to a value of type C without error.

🙂 Expected behavior

C and D are treated as distinct types like A and B, so the same error happens, ie. that the property #a of type D refers to a different member that cannot be accessed from within type C (typeof c).

Additional information about the issue

This would enable the ability to create new distinct class types dynamically which would be great for when you want to make unique types that cannot be satisfied by any other value.

Activity

  1. MartinJohns commented on Oct 23, 2025

    @MartinJohns
    Contributor

    Duplicate of #56146.

  2. RyanCavanaugh commented on Oct 23, 2025

    @RyanCavanaugh
  3. MartinJohns commented on Oct 23, 2025

    @MartinJohns
    Contributor

    There's an open PR #60885 by Mateusz Burzyński (@Andarist) that would make use of #fields in class expressions an error.

  4. locked as resolved and limited conversation to collaborators on Jan 7, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions